Process and engagement
What are provisional sums and prime cost items in a construction contract?
A provisional sum is an allowance in the contract price for work that cannot be priced exactly at tender. A prime cost item is an allowance for buying a product that has not been chosen yet. Once the real cost is known, it replaces the allowance and the contract price goes up or down, with any margin applied as the contract sets out.
Both are allowances: amounts in the contract price that stand in for costs nobody can fix at tender. They let a tender be complete when part of the scope cannot be priced exactly yet.
The difference is what they cover. A provisional sum is for work and a prime cost item is for buying a product, though some contracts treat a prime cost item as one kind of provisional sum, so the contract's own definitions decide.
Provisional sums
A provisional sum covers work whose extent is unknown at tender. On a school or council project, that is usually work hidden in the existing building or in the ground, such as repairs behind linings that have not been opened, or a service connection whose size depends on the authority.
The contractor carries out the work, and the actual cost replaces the allowance.
Prime cost items
A prime cost item covers a product the client still has to choose, such as tapware or a floor finish. The tender includes installing it, and the allowance covers buying it.
The adjustment
When the cost is known, it replaces the allowance. If the real cost is higher, the contract price rises, and if it is lower, the price falls.
Whether a margin applies to the difference, and how much, is set out in the contract. That clause is worth reading before the tenders are compared.
Too many allowances
Every provisional sum is a piece of the price that has not been fixed. A tender carrying many of them looks complete but leaves the risk on those items with the client, and two tenders with different allowances are hard to compare.
Fewer allowances
A provisional sum usually stands in for information that was missing at tender. Site investigations, a hazardous materials register, as-built drawings and a survey let a contractor price the work instead of allowing for it, as covered in what a client should provide at tender.
Products chosen before tender remove prime cost items altogether.
Provisional sums and variations
A provisional sum covers the work it describes. Work outside that description is dealt with under the contract's variation clauses, set out in how variations are managed.
On a fixed window
On a school holiday project, an open prime cost item is also a programme risk. A product chosen late is ordered late, and a late order can cost the handover date, as explained in long-lead items and early procurement.
Monument's approach
Monument manages each project end to end through a single point of contact, from tender through to handover and the end of defects. Whatever allowances the contract carries, questions about them go to that one contact from the first price to the last.
Related
Monument Environments
Boutique principal contractor for NSW government and institutional clients, specialising in construction inside operational environments that cannot be shut down. Established 2006. ISO 9001, 14001 and 45001 certified. Prequalified SCM 0256 and SCM 1461.
